@ Dim Jim: Finally, an honest assessment. His rush of blood cost you a place in the 2010 CL final. You had the upper hand against Bayern until his needless red card.
What's more worrisome than his shocking defending is his petulance. Did you see the little hissy fit he was throwing when Juan smacked some sense into him? And then refusing to acknowledge Menzes when being substituted. B/Prat. Fergie should bench him and give Fabio a run to see what he's made of.