Nicky Butt is singlehandedly keeping NUFC in the relegation zone. He has committed two penalties this year that have cost us 3 points in each match. Then today he commits a stupid foul at the top of the box thereby giving Richardson the opportunity to bury us. Why is Butt in the starting line-up each week? He is past his prime, has no speed, no creativity and has now become a huge liability in the defensive third of the pitch.