Liverpool Message Board
you are viewing a single comment's thread.view the rest of the posts
Lets buy a striker who is down to rock bottom moral wise and is miss firing. He would be hated by a large amount of the crowed just to make him feel better lol.
So get rid of one striker who really hasn't played enough. For another striker who ain't on form either. Lets all be glad that Mel isn't the boss : )
Got to agree with you here Andrew. I know the argument that Torres is a great player just going through a purple patch, but its one heck of a long dry spell. Remember he was not exactly firing on all cylinders with us last term, has not hit any kind of form with Chelsea, so really has been underachieving for more than a season and a half.
In fact if anyone was to use the "form is temporary while class is permanent argument, then surely the same could be said about Carroll. If Torre's poor form of 18 months is temporary, then since Carroll was firing well with Newcastle before his injury last season (and the season before) then his so called dry patch would look like nothing more than a blip.
While being realistic as others have already said this is highly unlikely to happen as I doubt Chelsea would sell. While Roman may have money to waste I doubt his ego would allow him to effectively pass us 30M. Besides I think unless Chelsea have another striker already lined up to arrive in January, or they have huge faith that Sturridge can be consistent as a lone striker, I think they are looking for Torres to step up in the new year while Drogba is away at the African Cup of Nations.
But it maybe a non starter from our side also. Kenny has made it quite clear that he only wants players who want to be with the club. Personally I would have liked us to keep Meireles, but it seems obvious that as soon as the club knew he wanted a move it was better to cut bait. Its exactly the same with Torres.
Lastly I don't think the so called Suarez/Torres partnership would bear much fruit, even if Torres was to figure out where the goal was. Torres is a needy player who while on form is one of the best natural finishers in the game, needs quality service, and 9 players behind him supporting him. It worked well when Torres had Gerrard or Alonso behind him laying on perfect balls for him to latch onto, and I do think Torres would benefit working with Adam, I don't see looking at playing style a natural collaboration between Luis and Fernando.
I understand your views Andrew but the saying "form is temporary but class is permanent" would seem to be tailor made for Torres. As you have rightly pointed out the guy is suffering a dip in form but he is still a classy player, with the right management and right atmosphere there is no reason he cant regain his sharpness in front of goal. Carroll on the other hand may display good form once in a while but there is no denying that compared to Torres he is a no-hoper.
Torres would not be the first "prodigal son" to come back so to speak, Ian Rush had a dreadful year at Juve but when he came to us continued scoring like he had never left. Who knows Torres might just do the same. And if we get him for 20million it would be like we had loaned him to Chelsea for 30 million pounds. The thing is we are creating chances by the bucketful and with Torres in the side some of those easy chances may just get converted.
As I said in my post there is very little chance this could happen but I am sure that I am not the only fan who wishes it would, just like you are not the only one Andrew who does not want it to happen.
It's just a thought,
- 1 Reply to mel n
I am 100% with you mel, I would love to have our nando back, I think his link up with suarez could be a work of sheer beauty.
We got the best out of him a couple seasons back, even if he didnt link with suarez that well (big if) he was exeptional with stevey G.
Loan carroll dont get rid, but yeah defo have el nacho back but big if very unlikely indeed.