• Liverpool Message Board

you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the posts
  • colin colin Mar 29, 2013 11:36 Flag

    Rodgers' error that could have cost top 4..

    Jason...Ive been posting up my suspicions about Rogers and his playing his fave-boy from Swansea for quite some time, before it was revealed he had this shoulder injury. Even he hadnt had the shoulder injury his shockingly bad form should not have even earned him a spot on the bench let alone starting him...too right it was a huge mistake by Rogers...in my book another huge mistake to add to plenty of others hes made since his arrival. He is making all these mistakes while he learns his trade as a manager he should have been making his mistakes and learning his trade elsewhere we are too big a club to put up with his apprenticeship ..we should have brought someone with proven experience in to manage our club a journeyman not an apprentice.

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • Well Colin,
      I agree there have been other mistakes, but for me this is the biggest in particular because Allen went from very good, to very bad in a quick period of time and none of us could really figure it out. I appreciate the fact they didn't want to make excuses, but I don't appreciate finding out how truly bad it was, and for whatever reason he was selecting him recently after a stint on the bench. It does raise a fair question about how Lucas is getting on, and quite obvious he's not at his best after the knee, but brings up Jordan and Jonjo

      I think BR has gotten a lot of things right, and while I know you're not a fan along with others, in grand scheme of things I'm happy with things he's done, especially since we haven't had a manager who's had to deal with the plethora of issues he has, rather than just being a manager. But I hope in hindsight, he's learned his lesson here, and it will help him focus on what else he needs in the summer aside from the names we can feel fairly certain about, and the others we may cross our fingers over.

      This summer will be critical for both Allen and Borini. Fortunately both are very young and we've at least seen what Allen can do on a good day, whereas Borini has not impressed and had 6 months of injuries. He was a very good player at Roma, but he's got to show something this summer or we need to #$%$ adding another striker or two.

      • 2 Replies to Jason
      • Jason...Im as u say not the biggest fan of BR. I do however think he has got certain things right since he took over getting everyone from the Academy on up to play to the same system seems to me a great idea. We seem incapable of consistency, yes we are going to lose some but its the manner in which we have lost some of those games that disturbs me...we play out of our skins v Spurs show plenty of spirit plenty of fight then next game go to St Mary's and...well...u know the rest of the story and that for me is down to BR he has responsibility for the gross inconsistency of his charges. If anyone feels he shouldnt shoulder that responsibility then I d like to ask them just what they think his responsibilities are as our manager ?
        This patience with both Borini and Allen I dont understand I think neither of these players is ever going to make the grade here. Borini Im sure will be shown the door before the season opens...does anyone know what his salary is ? Allen im sure BR will give him every chance and more if necessary mores the pity cos think he has no real ability better to let him show up play a few games after injury and get him in the shop window but doubt that will happen 25 mill for these two and everybody is moaning bout 35 mill for Andy C ? How much you think these two would return in the transfer market this summer best thing to do with em is offer em up as makeweights in some deal them plus cash for a player we want. Just hope we dont end up with Williams from Swansea...that would complete the hat trick of Ex Swansea deadlegs !

      • Just a slightly different angle guys. Fair points made by both of you by the way. What if Rodgers felt he had no choice because he simply doesn't think the other midfielders aren't good enough. For me that area of the pitch, with or without Allen has been both good and bad for us this year and is the root cause of our inconsistency. I also read that we're interested in the Ajax player Eriksson and along with Ince suggests that we're looking to strengthen that area.

        I'm just playing devils advocate because I think our midfield really needs some work.

    • I agree Colin.. FSG should've appointed a proven quality manager then hired Rodgers as his assistant. cos Rodgers isn't good enough or experienced enough to take the reigns of such a big club as ours.