Pastor Fired From Methodist Church For Marrying Lesbian Couple

Carol Kuruvilla
HuffPost

The firing of a Tennessee pastor by the United Methodist Church after leaders discovered she performed a lesbian wedding has spotlighted divisions within America’s third-largest religious denomination over its stance on homosexuality.

Anna Golladay was licensed by the UMC’s Holston Conference to serve at the St. Marks and St. Elmo churches in Chattanooga, two congregations predominantly composed of queer Christians and their allies. A local district committee on ministry voted to rescind Golladay’s license on Feb. 26, after an anonymous source shared a photo of the pastor from the same-sex wedding.

Congregants were deeply upset when they heard the news, according to Rev. Gary Ihfe, lead pastor of both churches.

“Words were shouted, tears were shed, hugs were given, and prayers were said,” Ihfe wrote in a March 5 Facebook post. “I am so sorry for the pain that is being felt by many of our families who feel as though they have come under attack.”

Golladay said her congregations have been “irreparably harmed” by the decision.

“The pain doled out by The United Methodist Church must stop,” she wrote in a blog post. “The continued minimization of our queer friends is not acceptable and should boil up in us a level of outrage that we can no longer control.”

The UMC, which has more than 7 million members in the U.S., forbids its pastors to officiate same-sex weddings. The UMC’s Book of Discipline, which details its laws and doctrines, states that “the practice of homosexuality is incompatible with Christian teaching.”

Disagreements about that approach toward homosexuality have caused deep ruptures within the denomination. Some factions of the American church are in favor of allowing same-sex marriages and accepting gay clergy members, but many UMC leaders from Africa and Asia oppose those moves. 

St. Marks and St. Elmo are part of the Reconciling Ministries Network, a U.S.-based organization that works for the inclusion of LGBTQ people in the UMC.

UMC bishops are currently reviewing suggestions on how to keep the church united despite its disagreements over sexuality. The bishops will present their final recommendation to the denomination’s top decision-making body, the General Conference, in February 2019.

Jan Lawrence, the network’s executive director, criticized the firing of Golladay while the church is still debating its approach toward homosexuality.

“This action was unnecessary, and deprived two churches of a beloved pastor without any input from the congregations,” Lawrence said in a statement. “Actions taken against clergy and licensed local pastors during this period, while the Council of Bishops is working on their recommendation to the church, serve only to cause harm.”

In her blog post, Golladay said that she began serving at St. Marks in 2016 and at St. Elmo’s in 2017. Golladay was appointed to these churches as a licensed local pastor, which means she was technically not ordained in the UMC. Instead, she was permitted to preach, conduct worship and perform other duties of a pastor at those specific congregations.

Golladay said that the two women whose wedding she performed are members of one of her churches. One of them has been part of it for many years, “giving her whole self to ensure the success of the community,” Golladay said.

Rev. Randy Martin, superintendent for the UMC’s Scenic South District, confirmed to HuffPost that he was sent a photo from the wedding and a copy of the women’s marriage license. 

Martin turned the issue over to the local district committee on ministry, a church body tasked with reviewing the certification of licensed pastors.

“Anna made the decision to violate her oath to abide by the Discipline,” Martin told HuffPost in an email. “The District Committee on Ministry upheld their responsibility to hold clergy accountable” by revoking her credentials.

 (Courtesy Reconciling Ministries Network)
(Courtesy Reconciling Ministries Network)

Barry Condra, a gay congregant who has been a member of St. Elmo’s for 15 years, told the United Methodist News Service his first instinct when he heard about Golladay’s dismissal was to “just run and leave the church.”

He decided to stay to help counsel newer members who had been “hurt and wounded yet again from organized religion.”

Golladay noted in her blog post that the UMC expects pastors to introduce congregants to Jesus and to care for them through the joys and challenges of life, from baptisms to funerals. But, she said, the church restricts pastors from caring for LGBTQ members during one of the most pivotal moments of their lives ― their weddings.

Referring to the one longtime congregant, she said, “I am expected to care for her, to be in covenant with she and her family 365 days a year and for their entire lives. The United Methodist Church would agree with that … except on one day and in one scenario.” 

  • This article originally appeared on HuffPost.

What to read next