Will Trump and North Korea's Kim Jong Un Make Peace? History Says No, Photos Say Maybe

Tom O’Connor
Newsweek

North Korean supreme leader Kim Jong Un's New Year's offer to talk peace with his U.S.-backed southern rival has already broken inter-Korean and international precedents, but history shows that efforts to solve the decades-long conflict and mounting nuclear crisis have sometimes fallen apart when they appeared most likely to succeed.

Last year, Kim Jong Un brought his country into uncharted territory when he oversaw the successful launched of intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs) capable of reaching the U.S. mainland, as well as a powerful hydrogen bomb test. Following arduous behind-the-scenes talks, South Korean officials relayed a personal invitation from the young supreme leader to Trump, who was set to become the nation's first sitting president to meet a North Korean ruler.

This overture was accompanied by South Korean claims that Kim Jong Un had agreed to put denuclearization on the table. Kim Jong Un took things a step further Friday by announcing an immediate freeze to nuclear tests, missile launches and the shuttering of the Punggye-ri Nuclear Test Site "to ensure the transparency of the suspension of the nuclear test."

Trending: Corpses of Executed Prisoners Used In Real Bodies Exhibition, Campaigners Say

In the same speech, Kim Jong Un then reiterated his support for "global nuclear disarmament." Nevertheless, the North Korean leader makes no mention of his own country's denuclearization, raising fears that he and Trump may end up playing the same geopolitical games as their predecessors.

RTR2VFNR
RTR2VFNR

A combination photograph shows North Korean founder Kim Il Sung (L), late supreme leader Kim Jong Il (C) and his youngest son and current ruler Kim Jong Un (R). Kyodo News Agency/Reuters

Kim Jong Il, the young leader's father, "played all the great leaders," Sung-Yoon Lee, a Korean studies professor at Tufts University's Fletcher School, told CNBC this week. "Kim Jong Un is simply stealing pages from his daddy's book," he added. 

RTS1FUYS
RTS1FUYS

A series of maps published October 10, 2017 show missile testing sites used by three generations of North Korean leaders. The youngest of the three, Kim Jong Un, debuted his country's ICBM technology with two tests in July 2017 and an additional, even longer ICBM launch from the vicinity of Pyongyang in November 2017. THE CNS NORTH KOREA MISSILE TEST DATABASE/NUCLEAR THREAT INITIATIVE/REUTERS

North Korea has previously hinted it would be willing to give up its nuclear weapons—but at a cost. North Korea argues its nuclear weapons program was designed for defensive purposes, a point Kim Jong Un also highlighted in his speech Friday. The program was conceived under the country's founder and Kim Jong Un's grandfather, Kim Il Sung, around the time of the Sino-Soviet split in the late 1950s and early 1960s. As the Soviet Union and China fell out, North Korea invested in its own weapons of mass destruction to deter a potential U.S. invasion.

North Korea became a party to the Non-proliferation of Nuclear Weapons Treaty in 1985, but the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) became increasingly critical as it reported inconsistencies in the reports and the U.N. Security Council became involved. On June 13, 1994, Kim Il Sung withdrew from the IAEA and, less than a month later, he died.

His son, Kim Jong Il, inherited the nuclear program and the international crisis that accompanied it. The U.S. and North Korea established the Agreed Framework in October 1994, through which administration of President Bill Clinton committed to providing heavy oil and light-water reactors to North Korea in exchange for a nuclear freeze. In 1996, the U.S., North Korea, South Korea and China sat down for the Four-Party Talks.

Don't miss: Organ Donation: 7-year-old Boy Becomes First Child to Undergo Five-organ Transplant

Related: U.S., Russia and China Respond As North Korea's Kim Jong Un Freezes Nuclear Tests

Diplomacy continued mired in mutual distrust into the 21st century as President George W. Bush placed North Korea on his "Axis of Evil," alongside Iran and Iraq, in 2002. The Bush administration accused North Korea of secretly enriching uranium for nuclear weapons and the U.S. and its allies stopped sending heavy oil to North Korea, which then withdrew from the Non-Proliferation Treaty in January 2003.

That August, multinational talks were restarted, this time with Japan and Russia also on board. The Six-Party Talks progressed until 2006 when North Korea demanded the U.S. unfreeze Pyongyang's financial assets in Macau, the U.S. refused, treating it as a separate issue. North Korea responded by holding its first nuclear weapons test in October 2006, citing "hostile U.S. policy," a phrase repeated to this day as the justification for North Korea's nuclear weapons program.

rtx3kawb0_0
rtx3kawb0_0

A graphic published on November 29, 2017, gives a comprehensive look at the series of missile tests last year in which North Korea demonstrated advanced technology. These launches led up to current talks with South Korea. CNS NORTH KOREA MISSILE TEST DATABASE/NUCLEAR THREAT INITIATIVE/DAVID WRIGHT/GLOBAL SECURITY PROGRAM/UNION OF CONCERNED SCIENTISTS/REUTERS

rtx3ej2u_0
rtx3ej2u_0

A graphic published after North Korea's sixth and most powerful nuclear test on September 3, 2017, looks at North Korea's nuclear and missile programs. CNS NORTH KOREA MISSILE TEST DATABASE/NUCLEAR THREAT INITIATIVE/CENTER FOR STRATEGIC AND INTERNATIONAL STUDIES/NORSAR/REUTERS

Following its first nuclear test, North Korea became increasingly isolated from the international community as it accelerated its nuclear aspirations. Kim Jong Il died in December 2011, leaving Kim Jong Un to succeed, making him the world's youngest head of state at the time. While Kim Jong Un wasn't afraid to cry at his dad's funeral, he quickly began to adopt an iron fist toward some of his country's military and political elite.

He purged a number of high-ranking individuals, including his own uncle. Jang Song Thaek. who was seen as a close ally of Kim Jong Il as well as China. Kim Jong Un then embarked on a ruling style some experts have described as being more like his grandfather than father. Kim Jong Un appears to have inherited both his predecessors' knack for benefitting off international rivalries. The youngest Kim's decision last month to first invite Trump to direct talks and then make his debut visit to China, may be part of a wider play to divide and conquer the world's two biggest economic powers as they contend for influence in the Asia-Pacific.

Most popular: How Exercise Can Change the Human Brain and Prevent Disease | Opinion

While many observers and officials have argued that Trump appeared to be "buying a pile of magic beans" in accepting Kim Jong Un's talks, as a frustrated Senator Chuck Schumer put it, signs have emerged that this round may turn out different. Kim Jong Un sent his own sister, Kim Yo Jong, as part of a high-level delegation to South Korea's Winter Olympic Games, making her the first member of the ruling family to cross the world's most heavily militarized border established after the bloody Korean War.

North Korea's state-run media has also been notably absent of the constant barrage of attacks against U.S. imperialism, even as the Pentagon went through with joint military drills held annually with South Korea. For the U.S.'s part, it suspended the drills for the length of the Olympics and did not send nuclear assets to the exercises, which were set to last about half as long as previous years.

Satellite imagery from 38 North has also been closely paying attention to developments in relation to North Korea's Yongbyon Nuclear Research Center and the Punggye-ri Nuclear Test Site. In its latest report, the authors noted "unusual activity" at the latter just ahead of Kim Jong Un's announcement Friday that it would be closed.

Fig1_Punggye-Upd-18-0424_AIR-1024x768
Fig1_Punggye-Upd-18-0424_AIR-1024x768

Satellite imagery shows the West Portal of the Punggye-ri Nuclear Test Site in northern North Korea, March 20, 2018. North Korea has been tunneling this part of its only known nuclear site since conducting its sixth and most powerful nuclear test on September 3, 2017, but activity reportedly died down in April. Airbus Defense & Space/38 North

Fig2_Punggye-Upd-18-0424_DG-1-1024x768
Fig2_Punggye-Upd-18-0424_DG-1-1024x768

Satellite imagery shows the West Portal of the Punggye-ri Nuclear Test Site in northern North Korea, on April 20, 2018. 38 North analysts noted "at least eight carts appear to have been connected in an unusually long train and parked out on the spoil pile" and the appearance of " a small bright object, possibly a shack." DigitalGlobe/38 North

"The appearance of a significant number of mining carts parked out on the West Portal’s spoil pile is unusual and its purpose remains unknown. Given Kim Jong Un’s announcement, it may be the first visible indication that North Korea intends to cease further tunneling at the Punggye-ri Nuclear Test Site," the report noted.

"Such an assessment is purely speculative at this point, requiring additional imagery and analysis over the coming days and weeks to determine if this is indeed the case, and whether or not the Punggye-ri nuclear site is actually being closed down," it added.

In true North Korea fashion, Kim Jong Un has yet to publicly place denuclearization on the agenda of his upcoming meet with Trump, or a summit alongside South Korean President Moon Jae-in. However, the two have reportedly discussed signing a peace treaty that would officially end the Cold War-era conflict, as Trump pointed out last week.

After a year of engaging his opponent in a year-long public spat, Trump appeared to change his tone Tuesday, calling Kim Jong Un "very open" and "very honorable," after meeting with French President Emmanuel Macron. Trump noted the difficult history of the U.S. and North Korea, but credited his own "maximum pressure" campaign of military buildup and extreme sanctions, with altering the status quo.

"A lot of promises have been made by North Korea over the years, but they've never been in this position," he added.

This article was first written by Newsweek

More from Newsweek

What to read next

By using Yahoo you agree that Yahoo and partners may use Cookies for personalisation and other purposes