A partial tear to the medial collateral ligament in Henderson's right knee forced the cancellation Thursday of the entire UFC 151 card, which was slated for September 1 at the Mandalay Bay Events Center.
UFC president Dana White said light heavyweight champion Jones declined to fight Sonnen, whom he proposed as a replacement for Henderson. That would have kept the show alive, but White said when Jones wouldn't agree to meet Sonnen, he had no choice but to cancel the show.
"I'm stunned," White told Yahoo! Sports. "We've never had a situation where this happened before, where a champion wouldn't step up to fight."
Jones agreed to fight Lyoto Machida on Sept. 22 at UFC 152 in Toronto. It is a rematch of the main event of UFC 140, which Jones won by choking out Machida in the second round.
White heaped praise upon Sonnen for being willing to take the fight on such short notice.
"Chael's been out there talking all this crazy [expletive] about Jones, but he proved that he not only talks the talk, he walks the walk," White said. "I offered the fight to a couple of guys, and believe me when I tell you, nobody wants to fight Jon Jones on [short] notice. Nobody. But when I called Chael, that crazy [expletive] said, 'Not only will I fight him, but I'll get on a plane and fight him at Mandalay Bay tonight, if that's what you want.' "
Henderson said Thursday he injured his knee while defending a takedown in practice. He said it won't require surgery, but doctors advised him to stay completely off of it for three weeks. He said the knee "is pretty unstable right now."
He was devastated by the cancellation because he believed he had a great opportunity to upset the highly regarded Jones, who is rated No. 2 in the world in the Yahoo! Sports pound-for-pound rankings. He said he was willing to fight injured if he had any way of doing so, but said the lack of stability in his knee prevented that.
"This is the first time in UFC history that the champion wouldn't step up and fight [a replacement], and I was pretty shocked to hear that," Henderson said. "It's not like he's injured. It's unbelievable to me that he wouldn't take that 'the show must go on' attitude. If there was any way I could have gone, and any way that I thought I could give myself a chance to win, I would have done that."
In a bid to save the card, White called several fighters and offered them the match against Jones. None but Sonnen, though, wanted to take on Jones without the benefit of a full training camp.
Sonnen, a middleweight who announced during an appearance on Fuel TV on Aug. 14 that he would be moving up to light heavyweight for a Dec. 29 fight against Forrest Griffin, was willing to take the risk.
Sonnen, who was knocked out by middleweight champion Anderson Silva after missing a spinning back fist in a highly profitable rematch on July 7 in Las Vegas, said he never considered saying no.
"I was shocked and I'm shocked much more that the show was cancelled," Sonnen said. "We all have to pitch in and help. It surprised me [Jones turned down the fight]. That's the first time I can recall that happening."
Sonnen hadn't trained since he lost to Silva and conceded his weight was high. He declined to say specifically what he weighed on Thursday, but said he would have had a lot of work to do to make the 205-pound limit. However, he insisted he would have made it.
In a defence of Jones, Sonnen said "it's a big thing to ask of anybody," to take on a new opponent on such short notice. But he said it's much riskier for the person in his position, as the fighter who hadn't been training, than it would have been for Jones, who had been preparing for Henderson.
Even given his disadvantages, Sonnen said he thought he could win the fight.
"Of course I could have won," Sonnen said. "You have to realize, I fell down in my last fight and I didn't get back up. It's not like it was a hard match for me up to that point. I'm not going to fall down again."
Sonnen said he's unsure if he will fight Griffin as was originally planned on Dec. 29.
Neither Jones nor any representatives could be reached for comment.
White said the decision to cancel the show was the first time in more than 11 years owning the UFC he had to do that. The UFC cancelled a planned March show in Montreal, but that was before matches were officially announced.
- Jon Jones