Advertisement

Future of football or complete nonsense? World Cup fans can't decide if they love or hate VAR

Referee Joel Aguilar inspects the VAR screen before awarding a penalty to Sweden in their Group F fixture against South Korea. (Getty)
Referee Joel Aguilar inspects the VAR screen before awarding a penalty to Sweden in their Group F fixture against South Korea. (Getty)

VAR has made its debut in the 2018 World Cup – and it’s already dividing fans watching the action in Russia.

The Video Assistant Referee, which was trialled in the FA and Carabao Cups last season, has been introduced in Russia to help decide on goals, penalties, straight red cards and mistaken identity.

It’s not the first use of video assistance in a World Cup – goal line technology was used for the first time in Brazil four years ago.

Fans in Nizhny Novgorod await the VAR verdict during Sweden v South Korea. (Getty)
Fans in Nizhny Novgorod await the VAR verdict during Sweden v South Korea. (Getty)

The officials who help with VAR watch each match in a remote location (FIFA’s ‘VAR Room’), and have microphone connections to the in-game officials so they can tell them if a mistake is made.

VAR has already made game-changing decisions in Russia – France were awarded a penalty against Australia after a VAR review, while Sweden were also given a spot-kick after the referee initially waved ‘play on’.

Fans appear somewhat divided in their verdict of the controversial technology – some believe it slows football down too much and makes the game too much of a robotic formality:

 Danny Baker gives his no-nonsense verdict on VAR. (Twitter/Danny Baker)
Danny Baker gives his no-nonsense verdict on VAR. (Twitter/Danny Baker)
Another football fan gives his verdict on the controversial technology. (Twitter)
Another football fan gives his verdict on the controversial technology. (Twitter)

Some Twitter users were just amused by the concept of referees sat in a darkened room…

This fan on Twitter is learning to accept VAR… but only for the amusement factor.
This fan on Twitter is learning to accept VAR… but only for the amusement factor.

There was also this crafty acronym:

A Twitter user thinks up a clever acronym for the new technology. (Twitter)
A Twitter user thinks up a clever acronym for the new technology. (Twitter)

Others took issue with the fact that VAR is still essentially controlled by humans:

A fan on Twitter makes an interesting point about VAR… (Twitter)
A fan on Twitter makes an interesting point about VAR… (Twitter)
Sweden’s Viktor Claesson is tripped by Min-Woo Kim in the World Cup’s latest VAR-influenced penalty award. (Getty)
Sweden’s Viktor Claesson is tripped by Min-Woo Kim in the World Cup’s latest VAR-influenced penalty award. (Getty)
This fan does not believe VAR has improved decision-making in football. (Twitter)
This fan does not believe VAR has improved decision-making in football. (Twitter)
This fan (presumably Australian) had VAR in his sights after the Socceroos’ defeat to France. (Twitter)
This fan (presumably Australian) had VAR in his sights after the Socceroos’ defeat to France. (Twitter)
Another fan on Twitter voices their frustration about VAR. (Twitter)
Another fan on Twitter voices their frustration about VAR. (Twitter)

A huge number of fans, however, have accepted that VAR is here to stay – whether we like it or not – and have chosen to embrace video assistance referees as a necessary step in eradicating mistakes.

Gary Lineker endorsed VAR after it helped earn Sweden victory. (Twitter)
Gary Lineker endorsed VAR after it helped earn Sweden victory. (Twitter)
Many who were waiting for VAR to cause controversy believe they’ve been proved wrong. (Twitter)
Many who were waiting for VAR to cause controversy believe they’ve been proved wrong. (Twitter)
Some fans find it hard to believe there are others who don’t share their enthusiasm for the technology. (Twitter)
Some fans find it hard to believe there are others who don’t share their enthusiasm for the technology. (Twitter)
Antoine Griezmann is tripped during France’s game v Australia, in a decision which was given after VAR. (Getty)
Antoine Griezmann is tripped during France’s game v Australia, in a decision which was given after VAR. (Getty)
Some fans’ opinions were pretty short and sweet. (Twitter)
Some fans’ opinions were pretty short and sweet. (Twitter)
Former Liverpool defender John Arne Riise made it clear where he stood. (Twitter)
Former Liverpool defender John Arne Riise made it clear where he stood. (Twitter)
One fan claimed that even video technology can’t make up for human error. (Twitter)
One fan claimed that even video technology can’t make up for human error. (Twitter)

SLIDESHOW: The 32 star players for every World Cup nation (Click image below)