Brian Sørensen said he feared his Everton side had sustained another serious injury, as they await the outcome of a scan on their summer signing Inma Gabarro’s knee, after they were beaten narrowly by Manchester United in the Women’s Super League.

When the Spain midfielder Gabarro went down in agony near the corner flag in the first half, the sudden silence from the crowd said it all. For Sørensen, whose side had learned just a few days earlier that their Italy midfielder Aurora Galli had sustained a season-ending anterior cruciate ligament knee injury, it was the last thing he wanted to see.

Related: Aston Villa v Tottenham after Arsenal, United and City win: WSL clockwatch – live

“It’s not what any team wants. The problem for us is we are really hurting, it’s two key players for us. I feel powerless, I can’t do anything about it, but I really feel for her,” the Dane said of Gabarro. “[It is] not good. I think it’s a big one again. Let’s see when the result comes back, but it’s not good. It’s tough but let’s see what the scan says and take it from there.”

Gabarro, a promising summer signing from Sevilla, had landed awkwardly after an innocuous-looking coming together with the United left‑back Leah Galton and was clutching her leg in apparent distress. The physiotherapy team signalled immediately that she was going to have to be substituted and – after around seven minutes of treatment in front of a sympathetic cluster of United supporters – the 21-year-old was carried off on a stretcher, with her head in her hands.

By then, Everton were already trailing to a fourth-minute goal scored by their former player Grace Clinton. The England midfielder intercepted Justine Vanhaevermaet’s somewhat wayward crossfield pass and fully capitalised. She still had plenty to do but made easy work of turning past Megan Finnigan and firing past Courtney Brosnan from 10 yards. It was Clinton’s second goal in as many league games and proved to be the game’s winning goal.

Marc Skinner, the United manager, said of Clinton: “You always get the glory when you’re the goalscorer but her pressing was really good today. There were really good moments from her.”

That momentary lapse in concentration from Vanhaevermaet aside, the home team played some promising football in the first half and were frustrated when the Netherlands striker Katja Snoeijs’s close-range effort was blocked on the line by Maya Le Tissier. United, though, looked strong with their new midfield of Dominique Janssen, Clinton and Lisa Naalsund combining well.

Before kick-off, and for much of the first half, a small group of people just outside the stadium were repeatedly setting off fireworks behind Brosnan’s goal.

Sadly, there were not many sparks in the game itself, which was at times low on goalmouth action and clear-cut chances. Melvine Malard, on as a substitute for United, saw a left-footed strike well saved by Brosnan late on, after Hinata Miyazawa’s effort had earlier been blocked by Vanhaevermaet, but it was a relatively even game with little to warm the crowd on an unseasonably cold afternoon.

Nonetheless, the result gave the visitors a second win from their opening two games of the season and Skinner, who wished Gabarro well, said of the match: “The wind played a part for both teams. It was tight. I felt we did enough to win the game but it wasn’t going to be a landslide, I thought Everton were really good. They unfortunately got an injury early on which affected them. I’m happy with the three points and happy to come away with another clean sheet, so it’s a good start.”

Arsenal recorded their first victory of the Women’s Super League season as the Norway midfielder Frida Maanum scored in her third consecutive game in all competitions to secure for the north London club a 1-0 away win at an improving Leicester.

The England striker Alessia Russo pounced on a loose pass and unselfishly set up Maanum for the match-winning goal in the second half of a game that Jonas Eidevall’s side will have felt they should have won by a greater margin.

The defeat left Leicester with one point from their opening two league games under their new manager, the French coach Amandine Miquel, but she will have taken some encouragement from how much closer the scoreline was compared with the 6-2 defeat at home to Arsenal in the WSL last November.

Manchester City, who played out an entertaining 2-2 draw with Arsenal on this campaign’s opening weekend, also collected their first league victory of the season as the Jamaica striker Khadija Shaw, the Golden Boot winner last season, scored her first league goal of the season to give Gareth Taylor’s side a 1-0 win at home against Brighton.

Liverpool, who finished fourth last season, were held to a 1-1 draw at West Ham after Riko Ueki’s late header secured for the east London club their first point of the season. Ueki’s goal cancelled out the opener, scored early by Liverpool’s club-record signing, the Canada forward Olivia Smith. Ultimately, it was a case of deja vu for Liverpool, who were also pegged back by a late equaliser from the Japan striker in a 1-1 draw in the corresponding fixture last season, in another game where Matt Beard’s side were left frustrated.

The late kick-off in the WSL yesterday ended in dramatic fashion, as the Tottenham striker Bethany England scored a 96th-minute equaliser in their 2-2 draw at Aston Villa, denying Robert de Pauw a first win in charge of Villa.

In the Championship, the early‑season leaders Charlton extended their 100% winning start to four victories out of four, as they claimed a 2-0 away victory at Blackburn.

Tom Garry

Skinner, whose side opened with a 3-0 home win against West Ham eight days earlier, was also pleased to record a second successive clean sheet, saying: “[The goalkeeper] Phallon Tullis-Joyce was excellent again today.

“There was a lot made of ‘she’s trying to replace Mary [Earps]’ – she’s not. It’s not about replacing Mary. Phallon always had that quality, she’s just now got an opportunity to show it. She made some big saves, she was tidy. Her footwork was excellent today. It was a top performance.”