Sister Jean is no fair-weather fan!

After the Loyola Chicago Ramblers topped the Eastern Michigan Eagles 76-54 on Wednesday, Dec. 4, the beloved school chaplain kept with her tradition of offering a fist bump to the team as they went to the locker room – but some members of the team left her high and dry.

In a clip that has since gone viral on social media, the 105-year-old basketball fan is seen sitting in her wheelchair draped with her Loyola scarf, but when she extends her fist, at least two players are seemingly distracted by something else and look away.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Related: 103-Year-Old Sister Jean, Loyola Basketball Superfan, Throws Out First Pitch for Chicago Cubs

“Why’d they do Sister Jean like that? 💔” fan account College Basketball Content joked on X about the awkward encounter.

However, the NCAA legend, who celebrated her milestone 105th birthday in August, appeared to take it all in stride.

Sister Jean has served as the chaplain at Loyola University Chicago for more than 20 years. Born on Aug. 21, 1919, the beloved nun told PEOPLE on her 103rd birthday that her best secret to a long and full life is simple: "I sleep well and hopefully I pray well."

Back in 2018, then age 98, Sister Jean Dolores-Schmidt first became a social media sensation after watching from the sidelines as the Ramblers beat the Miami Hurricanes in a stunning upset during March Madness, en route to the Cinderella team's Final Four appearance.

Sister Jean had waited 33 years to see her team win a game in the NCAA Tournament before the upset.

Related: NCAA Icon Sister Jean Celebrates 105th Birthday

During an appearance on Good Morning America at the time, Sister Jean spoke out about her newfound fame and how faith plays a huge role in her support for the team. She says she prays with the team before their games.

“I say a prayer, but sometimes there’s a little more than talking to God in the prayer … We wanna be sure that, when the buzzer goes off, the numbers indicate that we get the big W,” Sister Jean said at the time. “I pray for the other team, perhaps not as hard.”

Read the original article on People