Cometh the hour, cometh the absolute bedlam. It all came down to the final over, a few wild minutes in which everything that could happen did, and quite a few things that couldn’t also did.

At the start of that over India needed 16 off six to steal victory. At the end of it Mohammad Nawaz had bowled nine, Virat Kohli had been bowled off a free hit (and run three byes), there had been a six, a no-ball, two wides, a catch and a stumping, and Kohli was running around with his arms in the air. “I honestly have no words,” he said a few moments later. “I have no idea how that happened.”

Related: Sam Curran takes five as England seal T20 World Cup win over Afghanistan

Kohli produced an innings for the ages to drag his side off the floor, scoring 82 off 53 balls, adding 113 for the fifth wicket with Hardik Pandya, and India won by four wickets, but these are just numbers.

This was an extraordinary game and an extraordinary night, an occasion as much about the noise that swirled around this enormous bowl, the contributions of all 90,293 actors present in a supporting role, as the 22 on the field. When Rohit Sharma was asked for his reaction at the end, he said: “I have no voice left.” And he will not have been alone in that.

There is no fixture like this in world cricket. All the nonsense that surrounds International Cricket Council tournaments, all the sponsorship snafus and organisational issues, are worth it just to force these sides together. Even two hours before the start the atmosphere around the MCG, among the streams of fans heading towards the ground from Melbourne’s city centre and the honking cars driving past them with more fans spilling out of the windows, was intoxicatingly raucous and joyful.

The noise from the stands varied throughout from extreme to absurd, with occasional very brief periods where one team’s supporters or the other’s briefly quietened. Both will have endured moments when they felt the game was lost.

Pakistan’s came quickly, after they had been put in to bat and within four terrific overs were 15 for two with their openers, Babar Azam and Mohammad Rizwan, who so regularly and greedily gobble up most of their innings and score most of their runs, both out. Bhuvneshwar Kumar and Arshdeep Singh were both sensational in these early overs, even if it was the latter, and later Pandya, who hoovered up most of the wickets.

Shan Masood came in at three and for a while, as he offered and survived two run-out chances, his judgment appeared to have been completely cooked in the cauldron, but having survived them he and Iftikhar Ahmed resuscitated his side’s chances with a partnership of 76. There was only a short period when Iftikhar truly reached top gear – amounting to little more than one mercilessly pulverised Axar Patel over – in which time he went from 25 off 24 balls to a half-century off 32, and for a few delicious moments Pakistan could ponder how far beyond 160 they might be able to go.

He was out two balls later and in the end they reached 159, thanks in part to a couple of entirely out‑of‑character shots from Shaheen Shah Afridi, who in the space of two balls doubled his career tally of both sixes and fours in this format.

Andrew Balbirnie, the Ireland captain, admitted his side’s batting must improve after they fell to a nine-wicket defeat to Sri Lanka in their Super 12 opener at the T20 World Cup.

Looking to build on their upset of West Indies, they instead set a simple target of 129 founded on Harry Tector’s 45 and Sir Lanka romped home with five overs to spare.

“Obviously we didn’t want to bat first. We were looking at 160 plus and we were well short of that,” Balbirnie said.

“We were never really in the game. We knew they had the threat of spin on a used wicket and it certainly looked that way given the way the result has panned out.

“As a batting group we back ourselves to bat well first or second. We’re going to have to look at ourselves and if we do bat first in the next game we need to put up a better fight.”

Ireland’s Super 12 campaign continues against England at the Melbourne Cricket Ground on Wednesday.

“A lot of us wouldn’t have played in a stadium like the MCG, it’s one of the biggest in the world. We’re very excited about that, especially playing against England,” Balbirnie said.

“We haven’t played them at T20 cricket in 10 or 11 years so that will be exciting in itself. It’s a great city and one that we really enjoyed the prep period in.”

Dasun Shanaka, the Sri Lanka captain, was delighted with a dominant performance ahead of Tuesday’s clash with champions Australia.

“I’m really happy with the way we played the game. That’s the cricket we wanted to play as a team. Everyone contributed,” he said.

Then it was India’s turn and, however awkwardly Pakistan started their innings, Shaheen, Naseem Shah and Haris Rauf ensured their opponents got it just as bad. At the end of their powerplay they were 31 for three, one run and one wicket worse off than Pakistan had been at the same stage, and a ball later Axar Patel was controversially given run out after a TV review, even though the ball was not in Rizwan’s gloves when he broke the bails.

This brought Kohli and Pandya together, and eventually they heaved India out of the doldrums. Perhaps they were not always in control of the chase, but at least they looked like they believed they were. There was no sense of panic as the overs disappeared and the required run rate climbed and finally, with three overs to go and 48 needed, they shifted gear.

Related: T20 World Cup 2022: team-by-team guide to the Super 12s stage

“We were always wanting to make sure we stayed in the game as long as possible,” Rohit said. “We’ve been talking constantly about it. No matter what the situation, you’ve got to believe you can pull through.”

That belief will never have been stronger. Shaheen’s final over went for 17 with three fours, Rauf’s last for 15 with two wonderful Kohli sixes, and that left 16 to find off the last. Time, at last, for the real drama to start.

“From the situation we were in, to come out with victory it has to be not just his best knock, but one of India’s best knocks,” Rohit said.

None can have been more memorable.

• This article was amended on 24 October 2022 to remove an image due to potential misidentification.