Advertisement

Jamie Carragher disagrees with Rio Ferdinand over current England line-up vs 'Golden Generation'

Rio Ferdinand ahead of the UEFA Champions League 2023/24 final match between Borussia Dortmund v Real Madrid CF at Wembley Stadium on June 1, 2024 in London, England.
-Credit: (Image: Marc Atkins/Getty Images)


Liverpool great Jamie Carragher had a surprisingly low-key international career. He retired with just 38 caps for England — and he disagrees with Rio Ferdinand over which of the current crop would have made it into the team alongside his 'Golden Generation' peers.

Carragher is almost uniquely qualified to discuss the difficulties of making it into that 'Golden Generation' side. He's openly admitted he never prioritized international football, but even so, it's odd that a player with 737 Liverpool appearances featured so little — and the sheer quality of the competition certainly played a part.

Indeed, Ferdinand was one of those boxing Carragher out, alongside the likes of John Terry and Sol Campbell. Further forward, there were greats like Steven Gerrard and Wayne Rooney, although the 'golden' moniker weighed heavily on a group that was never able to deliver silverware.

READ MORE: Liverpool transfer news LIVE: Leny Yoro boost, David Hancko 'talks', Nico Williams interest

READ MORE: Arne Slot offers glimpse into Liverpool management style with dressing room plan

Ferdinand was the first to propose his combined team, featuring members of the current side and the Golden Generation. He immediately made a change from the 2000s lineup, swapping out David James in favor of Jordan Pickford.

Kyle Walker then took the spot from Ferdinand's former teammate Gary Neville. But that was it in terms of changes, with the Manchester United great preferring the other nine members of the Golden Generation team to their modern-day alternatives.

His final XI was as follows: Pickford; Walker, Campbell, Terry, Cole; Beckham, Gerrard, Lampard, Scholes; Owen, Rooney.

Carragher was quick to weigh in with his own team on X. Despite the difficulties he had breaking into the Golden Generation, he has given far more credit to the existing England crop.

Jamie Carragher (ENG) (18) and Jozy Altidore (USA) (17). The England National Team tied the United States National Team 1-1 at Royal Bafokeng Stadium in Rustenburg, South Africa in a 2010 FIFA World Cup Group C match.
Liverpool legend Jamie Carragher was only ever on the fringes of England's 'Golden Generation'. -Credit:Andy Mead/YCJ/Icon SMI/Icon Sport Media via Getty Images

Concurring with the Pickford and Walker swaps in the back line, Carragher also removed Frank Lampard in favor of Declan Rice in midfield. David Beckham made way for Jude Bellingham, prompting a slight formation reshuffle, and Michael Owen dropped out to make room for Harry Kane.

Where Ferdinand's final team ended up with a 9-2 split in favor of the Golden Generation, Carragher was more even, giving the nod to five current players. Ferdinand did concede that the existing group would all make this hypothetical XI in the event that they win the Euros.

Liverpool.com says: Carragher's team looks more accurate here. While England has managed to avoid the label this time around, it is in another golden generation, with a number of hugely talented footballers.

Some of them haven't even made this conversation, not least Liverpool vice-captain Trent Alexander-Arnold, who is a generational talent. Ferdinand has perhaps been guilty of a little nostalgia.

That being said, Rice over Lampard is a particularly bold pick from Carragher. And Owen might not be thrilled about the snub from his old teammate!