Advertisement

Coventry City's Wembley penalty heartbreak sparks bid for significant change to game

Coventry City players during the penalty shoot-out of the Emirates FA Cup semi-final match at Wembley Stadium, London. Picture date: Sunday April 21, 2024. PA Photo. See PA story SOCCER Coventry. Photo credit should read: Bradley Collyer/PA Wire.
-Credit: (Image: © 2024 PA Media, All Rights Reserved)


Coventry City's FA Cup heartbreak at Wembley has been cited in a request to football’s lawmakers to trial staging penalty shoot-outs at both ends of the pitch.

David Dein, the former vice-chairman of Arsenal and the FA, is lobbying the International Football Association Board (IFAB) after witnessing the “triple whammy” which befell Coventry in last season’s FA Cup semi-final against Manchester United.

Coventry had just had a goal disallowed in the last minute of extra-time, which would have capped an incredible comeback, when two spins of a coin meant the penalties would be taken at the Manchester United end and the Premier League side were given the option to go first.

READ MORE: Heartbroken Victor Torp breaks silence over Coventry City's FA Cup hurt and Man Utd 'goal'

READ MORE: Why Coventry City will be a magnet for quality in the summer transfer window

Dein hopes IFAB will discuss it at future meetings, and says the Dutch football federation (KNVB) has volunteered to trial it in its national cup competition. The first IFAB meeting of this season’s cycle takes place on Tuesday, when its football and technical advisory panels convene.

Although the Sky Blues are seen as the latest club to suffer in a high-profile game, the genesis of the concept for Dein dates back to 2000, when Arsenal played Galatasaray in the UEFA Cup final in Copenhagen. Arsenal had to take their kicks in front of 20,000 vociferous and hostile Galatasaray fans, and lost the shoot-out 4-1.

Dein has gathered evidence that taking kicks at both ends has strong support among players and fans. Sixty-nine per cent of players favoured taking kicks in front of their own supporters, while only three per cent favoured taking them in front of opposition fans, according to a survey by world players’ union FIFPRO.

Meanwhile, feedback gathered by the Football Supporters’ Association found a minimum of 74 per cent supported the idea, and a maximum of three per cent opposed it.

“I hope it will be discussed, and I am going to push it as much as I can,” Dein told the PA news agency.

“The campaign is as much about fairness as it is to give fans the opportunity to encourage their players, and not be disadvantaged with an inferior view of proceedings going on at the other end of the pitch.”

Dein’s plan does not envisage the referee racing from one end of the field to the other. He points out there are five officials – the referee, two assistants, the fourth official and the reserve referee – available to administer the penalties at all major finals.

Do you think this is a good idea? Click HERE to have your say on the issue