NHL betting: Scoring is up across the league, but overs aren't a winning bet

In the NFL, scoring this season is way down compared to recent years. Bettors have been able to take advantage, as unders are 107-86-2, good for a 55.4% winning percentage. The opposite is true through the first two months of the NHL season. Goals are flowing at a rate that we haven't seen since 1994. Despite that, bettors haven't been able to take advantage.

Scoring is up, but overs aren't money

A quick look at Wednesday's NHL scoreboard tells you a lot about the current state of the NHL. The Buffalo Sabres defeated the Columbus Blue Jackets by a score of 9-4. The Edmonton Oilers found the net eight times in an 8-2 victory over the Arizona Coyotes. The San Jose Sharks and Vancouver Canucks played a 6-5 overtime thriller. The Calgary Flames beat the Minnesota Wild by a score of 5-3 in a fun back-and-forth affair.

This season, the NHL is averaging 6.42 goals per game. That's up from the 6.28 we saw last year. This is highest number of goals per game since the 1993-94 season. Wayne Gretzky led the league in points that season. It's been a while.

On the season, 22 of 32 teams are scoring at least three goals per game. Symmetrically, 22 of 32 NHL teams are allowing at least three goals a night. Eleven teams are allowing at least 3.5 goals a night, and eight teams are scoring at that rate.

Goaltending has also been subpar. The league average save percentage so far this season is just .904. That's the lowest save percentage we've seen since the 2005-06 season. Just seven seasons ago, the league average save percentage was .915. The average was .910 as recently as 2020. It's been a pretty rapid and steep fall.

One might think all of this means that overs have been a solid bet to open the NHL season. Surprisingly, that's not the case. Through the first 416 games of the season, we've seen 199 overs, 199 unders and 18 pushes on the total. A .500 record isn't nearly good enough to turn a profit when betting sports.

Oddsmakers have adjusted. The average NHL total is now 6.5 goals. Anyone who has been betting for a few years will remember the days when the average NHL total was 5.5 goals. Blindly betting overs doesn't work. The best strategy is to target specific teams. Which teams have been good over bets and which teams have trended towards unders?

The fun teams

When handicapping an NHL game to go over the total, you should usually look to target a team that can score but will also concede goals. The easiest path to cashing an NHL over is a game where you think both teams can reach at least three goals. Sure, you can cash the over in a lopsided game that finishes with a score of 6-1. However, you're much more likely to see goals in close games, where goaltenders get pulled late for extra attackers and potential empty net goals.

Which teams have been good to over bettors this season?

Buffalo Sabres

Fresh off a 9-4 win on Wednesday night, it's no surprise to see the Buffalo Sabres on this list. So far, the over is 15-9 in Sabres games this season. When you look at this team, it makes perfect sense. It's a young team littered with talented players like Tage Thompson, Alex Tuch, Jeff Skinner and Rasmus Dahlin. They score on average four goals a game.

However, they're also allowing 3.69 goals a night. That ranks bottom five in the league. Their goalies are stopping just 88.5% of shots they face, well below league average. With Eric Comrie injured, the Sabres are relying on 41-year old Craig Anderson and rookie Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen between the pipes. Goals have been aplenty on both sides of the ice in Sabres games.

COLUMBUS, OH - DECEMBER 07:  Tage Thompson #72 of the Buffalo Sabres is congratulated by his teammates after scoring a goal during the first period of the game agains the Columbus Blue Jackets at Nationwide Arena on December 7, 2022 in Columbus, Ohio. (Photo by Kirk Irwin/Getty Images)
The Buffalo Sabres have been money to NHL over bettors. (Kirk Irwin/Getty Images) (Kirk Irwin via Getty Images)

Florida Panthers

Florida led the NHL in goals last season, scoring an average of 4.11 goals per game. They are outside of the top 10 this year, scoring just 3.42 goals a night. Despite that, Panthers games are 16-8 to the over this season. The equation for Florida this season has been simple, bet the over when they start Sergei Bobrovsky. Bobrovsky is giving up over 3.7 goals per game and stopping just 88% of shots. The team's other goalie, Spencer Knight, is giving up 2.6 goals a night and stopping nearly 92% of shots. For some reason, the Panthers are splitting the goalies' games relatively evenly. As long as they do that, bet the over in games started by Bobrovsky and maybe stay away when Knight is between the pipes.

St. Louis Blues

Blues' goaltender Jordan Binnington took the NHL world by storm when he stepped in and won the Stanley Cup in 2019. Since then, Binnington has been at best an average NHL goaltender. This year, he's been bad. Binnington is stopping just 88.9% of the shots he's facing and giving up nearly 3.5 goals a game. Offensively, the Blues are doing enough, scoring over three goals per game. As a result, overs are 16-8 in Blues games.

Los Angeles Kings

The Los Angeles Kings have the worst team save percentage in hockey, stopping just 88% of the shots thrown at their net. As a result, they're giving up over 3.5 goals a game. Thankfully, their offense has kept them afloat as they rank top 10 in goals. That combination has resulted in overs going 17-9 in Los Angeles games so far this season.

Edmonton Oilers

New season, same questions with the Edmonton Oilers. We know they can score with MVP favorite Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl forming the best duo in the league. The Oilers signed Jack Campbell to solve their goaltending issues, and that hasn't worked. They're giving up over 3.5 goals a night so far this season, and Campbell has lost his grip on the starting job. Oilers' games are 14-9 to the over.

What about unders?

Most people like rooting for goals, so they lean toward betting overs. However, you can always bet the other side and take the under. Which teams have been playing the most under games so far this season?