Premier League history: Which decisions could VAR have overturned?

Manchester City v Liverpool
Vincent Kompany is only yellow carded after a lunge at Mo Salah. Manchester City win the game and the title. (3 January 2019) (Martin Rickett - PA Images via Getty Images)
Manchester United v Arsenal
Wayne Rooney wins a penalty for Manchester United and Arsenal are denied a 50th game unbeaten. (24 October 2004) (Matthew Peters via Getty Images)
Manchester City v Liverpool
Raheem Sterling's goal is ruled offside against Manchester City. Liverpool lose 2-1. (26 December 2013) (Andrew Powell via Getty Images)
Soccer - Barclays Premier League - Manchester United v Chelsea - Old Trafford
Didier Drogba scores the winner in a 2-1 win over United. But was Drogba in an offside position? (3 April 2010) (Martin Rickett - PA Images via Getty Images)
Manchester United v Manchester City
Johnny Evans is sent off against Manchester City and United go on to lose 6-1. United then lose the title on goal difference. Should Evans have been sent off? (23 October 2011) (Laurence Griffiths via Getty Images)
Manchester United v Tottenham Hotspur
Tottenham were winning 2-0 when Manchester United's Cristiano Ronaldo won a penalty. United went on to win the game 5-2, but did this turn the game and was there contact? (25 April 2009) (Neal Simpson - EMPICS via Getty Images)
Manchester City v Manchester United
Ashley Young brings down Sergio Aguero in the Manchester derby but no penalty is given. Manchester Utd win the game and City must wait to win the title. (7 April 2018) (Manchester City FC via Getty Images)
Chelsea v Tottenham Hotspur
Chelsea beat Tottenham 2-1 with a last-minute goal from Kalou. Replays suggest it was offside? (30 April 2011) (Darren Walsh via Getty Images)
Aston Villa v Fulham
Ryan Fredricks stamped on Jack Grealish earlier in the match but the referee took no action. Villa went on to lose the game 1-0. (Play-Off Final - 26 May 2018) (Barrington Coombs - EMPICS via Getty Images)
Manchester United v AFC Bournemouth
Charlie Daniels is 'karate kicked' by Eric Bailly but no penalty was awarded. Lukaku's then scores a winner that looks offside. (30 December 2018) (Robin Jones - AFC Bournemouth via Getty Images)
Wolverhampton Wanderers v Manchester City
Willy Boly's goal for Wolves means City take just a point from the game. Was it handball? (25 August 2018) (Shaun Botterill via Getty Images)
West Ham United v Liverpool
Sadio Mane's goal meant that Liverpool escaped the London Stadium with a draw. But was James Milner offside in the build-up? (4 February 2019) (Chloe Knott - Danehouse via Getty Images)
Manchester United v Aston Villa
Nemanja Vidic concedes a 5th minute penalty which Villa score, but Vidic is not sent off. (League Cup Final - 28 February 2010) (ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Sheffield United v Liverpool
Liverpool are awarded a penalty which allows them to share the points. Replays show there may not have been any contact. (19 August 2006) (Mike Egerton - EMPICS via Getty Images)
Manchester United v AFC Bournemouth
Tyrone Mings is sent off for an alleged stamp on Zlatan Ibrahimovic. (Julian Finney via Getty Images)
Arsenal v Burnley
Arsenal are awarded a stoppage time penalty, which they score to win the game. But was there an offside in the build-up? (22 January 2017) (Julian Finney via Getty Images)
Crystal Palace v Norwich City
Andy Johnson wins and scores a penalty for Crystal Palace which relegates Norwich. Was it a dive? (16 April 2005) (Jamie McDonald via Getty Images)
Norwich City v Crystal Palace
Cameron Jerome's spectacular overhead kick against Crystal Palace was ruled out for a high foot. Should it have been? (8 August 2015) (Stephen Pond via Getty Images)
Manchester United v Sheffield United
During the game, Luton Shelton latched on to a through-ball and Manchester United's Gabriel Heinze's only cause of action was to scythe him down. Replays suggest that he got nothing on the ball. (17 April 2007) (Tom Purslow via Getty Images)
Blackburn Rovers v Burnley
David Dunn scores a stoppage time equaliser for Blackburn. But was it offside and should it have been given? (17 March 2013) (Chris Brunskill via Getty Images)

Vincent Kompany’s ‘lunge’ on Mo Salah in last season’s decisive match has been voted the Premier League moment fans would most like to see reviewed by VAR, a study has revealed.

The controversial decision to award Kompany a yellow card, rather than a red, topped a list of 20 Premier League moments that fans would love to revisit with the new tech.

Had VAR, which will be used in the Premier League for the first time this season, been available and the decision overturned, the title may well have made its way to Anfield rather than the Etihad.

Coming a close second was a much talked about moment from the 2004/5 season, when a controversial Wayne Rooney penalty helped Manchester United to a 2-0 victory over Arsenal, preventing Arsene Wenger’s Invincibles from going 50 games unbeaten.

The poll, commissioned by Sky Sports, saw the top three is completed by another contested decision involving Liverpool, with Raheem Sterling’s goal for the Reds in 2013 chopped off for offside.

Again, the title made its way to Manchester, rather than Merseyside.

Former Manchester United and England defender Gary Neville said: "Football is a game of opinions and all fans will have moments in the past when they think 'if that had been different'.

"I know I've got memories playing for Manchester United and England when I've thought if only they could look at that one again.

"The hope for this season will be that VAR clears most of those moments up, seeing the system in action it's going to be fascinating to see how players react under that scrutiny every week."

Liverpool star Jamie Carragher added: "It was a pivotal game in the title race last season, who knows whether the call would have been different with VAR technology, but it's exciting to have it this season and it will be another interesting talking point.

"In my career there were plenty of moments when things could have been different with VAR technology, I was that type of physical player, but it will be interesting to see how that evolves now it's going to be keeping a closer eye on the players week in week out."

Gary Hughes, Head of Football at Sky Sports, added: “We know that VAR coming to the Premier League this season is going to be a big talking point.

"The Sky Sports team has spent the summer getting to grips with the technology and come Friday night we’ll be ready to go.”

The poll of almost 4,000 football fans via OnePoll also saw another controversial penalty award to Manchester United featuring in the top 10 – this time Cristiano Ronaldo going down against Tottenham with Spurs 2-0 up at the time.

Manchester United went on to register a thumping 5-2 victory.

As ever, fans can follow all the twists and turns of the new campaign across Sky Sports, starting with Liverpool v Norwich on Friday Night Football.

With 128 live matches, plus all the best features, interviews and analysis across Sky Sports’ digital platforms, plus in-game clips and match highlights, Sky Sports has got the Premier League covered.


Featured from our writers