Ajax desperately need a leader but time will tell if Jordan Henderson fits the bill

No small task awaits Jordan Henderson at Ajax. The England midfielder and former Liverpool captain must become the leader and inspiration of a mostly young, unbalanced and heavily criticised team.

This is a side who were knocked out of the Dutch Cup less than a month ago by opponents, USV Hercules, who do not even play at the highest amateur level. Ajax, by far the wealthiest club in the Netherlands and successful in the Champions League between 2018 and 2022, slumped to the bottom of the table in late October and are now fifth, nine points from the top three places that would entitle them to elite European football next season.

Related: ‘I’ve never tried to hurt anybody’: no regrets for Henderson on Ajax arrival

Fans, press and former players such as Rafael van der Vaart, Wesley Sneijder and Marco van Basten have been ruthless in their criticism. For them the “miserable way” Ajax have been playing is incomprehensible, particularly the state of the midfield and defence. But so, too, is the fact the team have to contest a playoff against Norway’s Bodø/Glimt next month to continue in the Europa Conference League; and that of the 10 fairly unknown players who arrived last summer, only one is considered suitable: the goalkeeper Diant Ramaj.

Criticism also comes from inside. “Lack of vision and leadership are the main reasons for the decline,” the experienced Remko Pasveer, Ajax’s reserve goalkeeper, said in an explosive interview with the Amsterdam newspaper Het Parool. “Many newcomers do not have the Champions League level that Ajax aspires to. And they don’t understand the club.”

Does Henderson understand this complex club, where the former coach Louis van Gaal has returned as an adviser, the former captain Danny Blind is back as a member of the supervisory board and the former player John van ‘t Schip has been appointed as the temporary coach, but which yearns for a fully fledged executive board? Does the 33-year-old still have Champions League quality?

That’s probably not even the most important thing. The versatile midfielder has a wealth of experience and has been praised for his work ethic and leadership. That is what Ajax need most after parting ways with the team’s talismans Daley Blind (one year ago) and Dusan Tadic (last summer).

“Two years ago, it was always busy in the gym even after training,” Pasveer says. “Players like Dusan Tadic, Davy Klaassen, Lisandro Martínez, Daley Blind, Antony or Sébastien Haller always wanted to get better and stronger, even in their spare time … I see less dedication among the current generation of players, and that worries me.”

With the arrival of Henderson fans are full of hope, cheered by the words of Pepijn Lijnders, the Liverpool assistant coach, who was consulted by Henderson about Ajax. Lijnders told the Dutch newspaper De Volkskrant: “He is a complete midfielder, full of character. He corrects his fellow players and coaches a lot, so that no one has a moment to not be focused. He was our captain all those years – that says it all. He takes the team in tow and can become the coach’s right-hand man.”

What adds to the enthusiasm is a sense of disbelief that the deal has happened. These days Dutch clubs don’t often succeed in attracting well-paid foreign players with such a proven record. PSV Eindhoven’s signing of German World Cup winner Mario Götze in 2020 is a rare modern example.

Related: Jordan Henderson has badly damaged his image – and that of the Saudi Pro League | Jonathan Wilson

Shirts with Henderson’s name on the back have been flying across the counter at the store at the Johan Cruyff Arena. Ajax fans have already given him a nickname (“Henny”) and a joker in Amsterdam crossed out an ‘a’ on a sign in the Amsterdam neighbourhood Jordaan so it reads Jordan.

“His arrival means a major boost in quality for our selection,” Van ‘t Schip says, although Henderson will not be able to face RKC Waalwijk on Sunday while he waits for a work permit. “A footballer of this calibre is also important for the many young players, both on and off the field.”

The fact that Henderson is 33 and has spent the past six months in the mediocre Saudi league raises some doubts in the Netherlands as to whether this will be a golden match. But there is hardly any talk about the ethical choice of Henderson to play in a country where homosexuality is prohibited, after he positioned himself in England as a strong advocate for the LGBTQ+ community.

Thijs Smeenk, a sports journalist and board member of the John Blankenstein Foundation, which promotes gay and lesbian rights, says he is happy with Henderson’s arrival. “In the Netherlands, gay acceptance is going backwards rather than forwards, including in football environments. It’s nice to welcome a player who really dares to speak out for the acceptance of gay people. We don’t have enough of that on our football fields. I assume that Henderson still stands for that.”